Z-Temp switch does not involve the sensing contacts at all, it goes in parallel with the bed thermistor. Since you've replaced the plate, it's probably not up at that end. The only thing left I can think of is that you've swapped the thermistor and sensing connector at the other end, in the electronics compartment. I don't remember offhand if they're the same type of connector or how to tell them apart; I'll try to have a look later today.